Centre-State Relations
Centre-State Relations for CGPSC Prelims and Mains: legislative, administrative and financial relations, Finance Commission, GST Council, Sarkaria and Punchhi.
Chapter Overview
Centre-State relations (केंद्र-राज्य संबंध) describe how the Constitution divides law-making, executive and financial power between the Union and the states. They sit in Part XI (Articles 245–263) and Part XII (Articles 264–293), with the Seventh Schedule as the master list. This is where India’s “quasi-federal” character is decided, and where today’s live disputes play out: Governors and assent to Bills, central agencies, GST, Finance Commission shares and river waters. For a Chhattisgarh aspirant the chapter has a strong local angle: the Mahanadi tribunal, the Central Zonal Council, the state’s share in central taxes, and the 2024 mineral royalty judgment.
What You’ll Learn
By the end of this chapter, you will be able to:
- Explain the three lists of the Seventh Schedule, residuary power (Art 248) and how Art 254 resolves conflicts
- List the five situations in which Parliament can legislate on State subjects (Arts 249, 250, 252, 253, 356)
- Explain the Centre’s power to direct states (Arts 256, 257, 365) and the cooperation provisions (Arts 258, 258A, 261, 262, 263)
- Describe the Inter-State Council, Zonal Councils and All-India Services
- Explain how tax revenue is shared (Arts 268–271), the role of the Finance Commission (15th and 16th) and the GST Council
- Compare the ARC, Rajamannar, Sarkaria and Punchhi recommendations and the S.R. Bommai judgment
- Write balanced Mains answers on cooperative federalism with a Chhattisgarh angle
Prerequisites
- Preamble and Salient Features of the Constitution — the federal and unitary features of the Constitution
- Parliament and State Executive and Legislature — the two sets of institutions whose powers are being divided
Learning Path
Follow the topics in this order:
graph TD
A["1. Legislative Relations
Arts 245–255, three lists,
Arts 249–254, Governor's assent"] --> B["2. Administrative Relations
Arts 256–263, ISC,
Zonal Councils, AIS"]
B --> C["3. Financial Relations
Arts 264–293, Finance Commission,
GST Council, royalty ruling"]
C --> D["4. Commissions
ARC, Rajamannar, Sarkaria,
Punchhi, Bommai"]
D --> E["5. Quick Revision
One-page sheet"]
E --> F["Next chapter:
Local Government in India"]Topics in This Chapter
| # | Topic | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Legislative Relations (Articles 245–255) | Territorial extent, Seventh Schedule, 42nd Amendment, residuary power, Art 246A (GST), Parliament in the State field, Art 254, Arts 200 and 201, the 2025 assent rulings |
| 2 | Administrative Relations (Articles 256–263) | Directions to states, Art 365, mutual delegation, full faith and credit, water disputes (Mahanadi), Inter-State Council, All-India Services, Zonal Councils |
| 3 | Financial Relations (Articles 264–293) | Tax powers, Arts 268–271, grants, Finance Commission (15th and 16th), GST Council, borrowing, the 2024 mineral royalty judgment |
| 4 | Commissions on Centre-State Relations | ARC 1966, Rajamannar, Anandpur Sahib, West Bengal Memorandum, Sarkaria, Punchhi, Bommai and the nature of Indian federalism |
| — | Quick Revision | Every article, body, number and case on one page |
Where It Is Asked
| Paper | What to expect |
|---|---|
| Prelims P-I (Part 1, India GS) | Article-number questions (249, 252, 254, 263, 275, 280, 293), list placement of subjects, Finance Commission chairs and shares, GST Council voting, commission chairs and years. Statement-based and match-the-following formats are common |
| Mains P-III (GS-I), Constitution and Public Administration | Short answers (Inter-State Council, Art 249, localised emergency, Finance Commission functions) and long answers (is India quasi-federal? the Governor’s role; fiscal federalism and GST; Sarkaria vs Punchhi) |
- High-yield: Art 249 (Rajya Sabha, two-thirds present and voting); 42nd Amendment’s five subjects; Art 254(2); ISC chaired by PM vs Zonal Councils chaired by Home Minister; Arts 268–271; 41% devolution (15th and 16th FCs); Sarkaria 247 vs Punchhi 273.
- Common mistakes: putting police or agriculture in the Concurrent List; saying residuary powers lie with states; calling Zonal Councils constitutional; assuming GST Council decisions are binding.
- Chhattisgarh angle for Mains: Central Zonal Council membership; the Mahanadi Water Disputes Tribunal (2018); the 2020 Art 131 suit against the NIA Act; 3.407% share under the 15th FC; Fifth Schedule and Art 275 grants; no President’s Rule since 2000 (as of 2026).
Quick Reference: the Chapter at a Glance
| Article(s) | Subject | Key point |
|---|---|---|
| 245–246 | Territorial and subject-wise division | Three lists: originally 97 / 66 / 47 entries |
| 246A | GST | Simultaneous power (101st Amendment, 2016) |
| 248 | Residuary power | With Parliament |
| 249 / 250 / 252 / 253 | Parliament in the State field | Rajya Sabha resolution / Emergency / states’ request / treaties |
| 254 | Repugnancy | Central law prevails; 254(2) exception with President’s assent |
| 256–257, 365 | Directions to states | Non-compliance can lead to Art 356 |
| 258 / 258A | Delegation | President → state / Governor → Centre |
| 262 / 263 | Water disputes / Inter-State Council | Tribunals; ISC set up 1990 |
| 268–271 | Tax sharing | Stamp, Sale, Share, Surcharge |
| 275 / 282 | Grants | Statutory / discretionary |
| 279A | GST Council | FM chairs; Centre 1/3 vote |
| 280 | Finance Commission | 16th FC (Panagariya): 41% for 2026–31 |
| 293 | State borrowing | Only within India |
Related chapters: Union Executive · Judiciary · Constitutional Bodies · Public Finance · Chhattisgarh: State Formation and Administration
Start Learning
Begin with the first topic: